Saturday, June 22, 2024
Saturday, June 22, 2024

Milwaukee Press Club 'Excellence in Wisconsin Journalism' 2020 & 2021 Award Winners

Reid Epstein: New York Times Reporter’s Disgraceful False Reporting About a Milwaukee Cop


“May Officer Michael Lutz rest in peace, and may Reid Epstein take his biased road show somewhere else and stay away from reporting on Wisconsin. Minimally, you should question every single fact he asserts.”

New York Times’ reporter Reid Epstein is trying to insert himself into the Wisconsin governor’s race as a political expert, writing comments slanted negatively against Republican Tim Michels. So it’s worth reminding readers of Epstein’s history in Wisconsin, namely his disgracefully false rush to judgment against a now deceased and decorated Milwaukee police officer.

His reporting on that story was SO BAD that anything Epstein reports should be questioned. In no way is Reid Epstein some authority on Wisconsin. Yet he keeps trying to pretend he is one, recently writing things like, “On Tim Michels, the latest Trump-backed Republican to topple a state GOP establishment this year. He did so by entertaining Trump’s most outlandish theories, including a pledge to consider signing legislation to withdraw the state’s 2020 electoral votes.”

Reid Epstein often writes about election issues, writing, “NEW: A tour of Wisconsin, where promising to restrict voting access may not be enough for a Republican electorate salivating to overturn the 2020 election, decertify the state’s results and withdraw electoral votes two years later.” Yeah, no bias there. His statement is false. The vast majority of the Republican electorate in Wisconsin is not salivating to overturn and decertify the presidential election.

The only decertification candidates on the governor and attorney general’s ballots got crushed by the Republican electorate. One of them couldn’t even break 6%. The facts don’t ever seem to get in the way of the biased narrative.

There has never been a better example of Epstein’s disgracefully sloppy reporting than the tragic story of now deceased Milwaukee police officer Michael Lutz.

The Reid Epstein Story on Michael Lutz

The story, with reporting led by Reid Epstein, was one of the most despicable episodes in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel’s history. I know because I was in the newsroom that day, and my byline ended up third on the story for a small addition unrelated to the false reporting. Epstein led the reporting on that story.

Here’s the AP version of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel article which, conveniently, is no longer available online. Note that the headline and first paragraph are false.

Reid epstein

Here’s the full tale. Back in 2003, when Reid Epstein was a Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reporter, a call came over the scanner that the Milwaukee police had shot a man. This was during a violent period in Milwaukee’s history, and a dedicated unit of Milwaukee police officers was charged with tracking down some of the city’s most violent gang members. They were such a presence in the inner city of Milwaukee that these officers were even given nicknames by residents. One of those officers was named Michael Lutz. The residents called him “green eyes.”

I remember it as if it was yesterday. The editors dispatched Reid Epstein to the scene. Another reporter was working with him, but she stayed in the newsroom. She’s not working in Wisconsin anymore so I’m going to leave her name out of it. Plus, she didn’t go to the scene, and she was relying on Epstein’s reporting. I had been working in the newsroom on a separate investigative piece about a broken use-of-force database. Before I went home that day, the editors asked me to submit an “insert” of a couple paragraphs about the broken database to Epstein’s story. It had nothing to do with the shooting.

Reid came rushing back to the newsroom from the shooting scene, all excited, saying that the cop had shot an “unarmed man.” I sent them my insert and left for the day. As I left, I saw Reid and the other reporter hunkered down, writing the story. I didn’t see what they were writing until the next morning.

The next day, I was shocked when I saw the newspaper. The story stated, as a fact, that the officer, later identified as Michael Lutz, had shot an “unarmed man.”

Except it wasn’t true.

The truth quickly revealed that Epstein’s reporting was false. He had taken the account of unreliable witnesses and stated their claims as fact. The problem isn’t that he interviewed or quoted the witnesses, of course.

It’s that he presented witnesses’ claims as incontrovertible fact at the top of the story, rushing to judgment against a police officer, without bothering to wait for the other side. It’s called attribution. Journalism 101. I’m not sure who wrote the headline – it might have been someone on the copy desk – but it derived from the reporting in the lead.

The police union called me the next day and asked me to come to their offices to clear it up because they didn’t trust Reid, and they knew I would be fair. They were apoplectic about his story. They let me listen to internal affairs recordings of the officers’ interviews. The suspect, Timothy Nabors, who survived the attack but was seriously wounded, was not unarmed, they said.

This eventually became provable fact. Reid Epstein had rushed to judgment against a Milwaukee police officer, and he was just dead wrong. Below is a later Milwaukee Journal Sentinel editorial that admitted the officer was “exonerated.”

It admits that some were too quick to believe the false claims; that included Epstein, though, which of course they don’t reveal. They then admit that the Journal Sentinel itself initially reported that Nabors was unarmed.

Again, attribution is Journalism 101. “Witnesses claim or say a man was unarmed” is different from “he was unarmed.”

Reid epstein
Reid epstein

It’s absurd for the newspaper to let itself off the hook in the above editorial, claiming they reported false information because the witness accounts were not “initially contradicted by Police Chief Arthur Jones or the officers involved.”

Jones was probably sorting out all of the information because the investigation was so fresh, and the officers were probably being interviewed by internal affairs. They were hardly available to immediately sit down for an interview with journalists right after the shooting, and it’s unreasonable to expect they would. The mistake was the newspaper’s failure to attribute at the top, and they should have owned it.

A former Milwaukee police officer who knew Lutz told us: “I worked with Lutz and Newport. Both outstanding cops, but Lutz was a different breed. He was the guy rallying troops to go back on the street after 10, 12 hours of work because he had another good tip about some violent criminal and we needed to go act on it now. He was one of a kind and rarely made mistakes. It says something when the streets give you a nickname. The amount of lives he saved everyday by just doing his job is incalculable. I can’t say enough good things about Mike. He is dearly missed professionally and personally.”

A criminal complaint later revealed: “A man critically wounded by a police officer after a traffic stop admitted he picked up a handgun moments before he was shot, according to a criminal complaint filed Thursday,” the Associated Press reported at the time. That complaint charged the man who tossed the gun to Timothy Nabors.

In other words, Nabors was not unarmed. “The other guy who I was with threw the gun by me, the gun hit the ground and I picked it up,″ Nabors told police that day, according to the complaint.

A key witness was criminally charged with obstructing justice. A 2009 Milwaukee Journal Sentinel story acknowledges, “The 2003 shooting prompted much public rancor after a woman said Nabors was unarmed when he was shot. She was later charged with obstructing justice, and Nabors admitted, as part of a plea bargain, that he had briefly picked up a gun another man had tossed toward him.”

Years later, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel admitted, “Lutz said Nabors had refused to drop the gun, and that he feared Nabors would shoot him or his partner, Dean Newport.”

The story blew up at the time, causing a lot of tension and uproar in the community. Lutz was white and Nabors was black.

What happened to Officer Michael Lutz in the years after this story is a complete tragedy. Does Reid Epstein have blood on his hands? Well, PTSD is a complicated thing.

For a time, Lutz’s career seemed to be going well. Two years later, he was shot in the line of duty, receiving a purple heart, but he retired on disability and earned his law degree. Then it took a horrific turn.

Michael Lutz died in 2015 from a self-inflicted gunshot wound after a brief tactical situation after police responded to a domestic-violence call. He was only 44 years old.

“Lutz is described as getting out of his vehicle with his badge in one hand, a gun in the other. He then put the firearm in his mouth,” a CBS-58 story horrifically reported.

At the time, the police union said, “Our brothers give much to the job. Michael Lutz was one of our warriors. He gave much to the job and it took its toll.” The story noted that he was a “John Doe whistleblower.”

“As a young adult Michael got his pilot’s license and loved to fly,” his obituary says.

“Michael Lutz was a 1988 graduate of Thomas More High School and a graduate from the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, and earned his Juris Doctorate from the University of Wisconsin-Madison Law School. Michael was a highly decorated and respected Police Officer with the Milwaukee Police Department where he started as a Police Aide at the age of 19 in 1989.”

It continues: “He later retired from the Police Department after being shot in-the-line of duty in 2005, for which he received a Purple Heart. After his retirement, Michael attended law school at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, earning his law degree. Once he earned his law degree he worked for the Milwaukee County District Attorney’s office as a special prosecutor, and as an adjunct instructor for Concordia University, and Bryant and Stratton College. Most recently, Michael started his private practice as a criminal defense attorney at Canfield & Lutz, LLC.”

Over the years, I have thought occasionally about Michael Lutz and what Reid Epstein and the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel did to him. To this day, I am absolutely enraged by his reporting and, to a lesser degree, by the fact he endangered my own reputation because my name was the third byline on his false story due to submitting an unrelated short insert.

May Officer Michael Lutz rest in peace, and may Reid Epstein take his biased road show somewhere else and stay away from reporting on Wisconsin. Minimally, you should question every single fact he asserts.

tommy thompson trump

Wisconsin Govs Tommy Thompson & Scott Walker Will ‘Criss-Cross’ State to Boost Trump

"The momentum is building" - Wisconsin GOP Chair Brian Schimming Former Wisconsin Governors Tommy Thompson and...
michael thurston

Waukesha County DA Candidates Slam Soft-on-Crime Policies Under Tony Evers

This is story 1 in WRN's 7-part series on the Waukesha County District Attorney's race,...
trump milwaukee

Trump and Milwaukee [Up Against the Wall]

Democrats love their cities. They know that people who move to cities are more likely...
david prosser

In ‘Petty’ Move, Liberal Justices Erase Conservative’s Name From State Law Library

The liberal partisans on the Wisconsin Supreme Court are erasing former conservative Justice David Prosser's...
dan bice

Stop the Presses! The Media Is Upset Brad Schimel Was Caught Speeding

Dan Bice left out a key sentence that changes the context. Stop the presses! The liberal...
tammy baldwin biden

Sen. Tammy Baldwin Says Biden Presidency Is ‘One of the Most Successful’ in Generations

Tammy Baldwin praised the "accomplishments" of the Biden administration. Wisconsin Democratic Sen. Tammy Baldwin insists that...
Wisconsin School Choice Lawsuit Expanding School Choice Kirk Bangstad Wisconsin school choice Milwaukee School Choice

Response to MPS Debacle MUST Include Expanded School Choice for All Families

No response to the regrettable MPS debacle will be adequate if it does not include...
trump milwaukee

7 Members of Congress DEBUNK Claim Trump Disparaged Milwaukee as a ‘Horrible City’

Seven members of Congress have debunked the misleading media claim that former President Donald Trump...
john e wall

John E. Wall: The Importance of Fathers [Up Against the Wall]

My father, John E. Wall, age 91, passed away on Monday, October 30th, 2017. He...
kamala harris most liberal

Voters Lack Confidence Kamala Harris Can Become President

Vice President Kamala Harris has a fight on her hands if she wants to inherit the Democratic presidential mantle after President Joe Biden’s time is over, according to a new poll.

The Politico/Morning Consult poll shows that voters have serious doubts about Harris’ electability.

The poll found only 14% of voters said it was “very likely” Harris would win a general election for president if she became the Democratic nominee. Another 20% said it was “somewhat likely.”

The poll is especially noteworthy given Biden's age. The incumbent president is 81 years old and appears increasingly in decline.

A moment of confusion for Biden at a June 6 D-Day ceremony went viral last week, the latest in a string of similar incidents. At the same time, Biden remains competitive with former President Donald Trump, though several polls suggest Trump has a lead over the president.

Biden's incidents have led some to speculate that Democrats could or should try to replace Biden at the Democratic convention in Chicago in August. That would be a highly unusual, though not impossible, move. Removing Biden would naturally raise the question about who could replace him, but for now voters seem to lack confidence that Harris could win.

The poll also looked ahead to 2028: “If President Joe Biden were not in the running for president in 2028, which of the following Democrats, if any, would you want to be the Democratic candidate for president?”

While Harris was top of the list among Democrats, she only received 21% support. California Gov. Gavin Newsom and Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg both received 10% support each, while 41% said they were unsure or didn't know.

Only 42% of those polled described Harris as trustworthy, and 44% described her as honest, according to the poll.

Notably, only 36% of those surveyed said Biden should replace Harris as his VP on the ticket.

trump convicted felon

Hell YES, I’m Voting For the Convicted Felon! [WRN Voices]

The dust has now settled after a period of time, when a former president was...

A Do-Over Is Needed on the $252 Million MPS Referendum [WRN VOICES]

By Steve Ewing Time to throw the challenge flag on the MPS referendum. Recently, voters in...
washington county da

Warring Law Enforcement Endorsements in Washington County DA’s Race

Candidates Barry Braatz and Mandy Schepper have each announced major law enforcement endorsements as the...

MPS Failed to Follow State Law by Not Filing Financial Reports With City Clerk

The Milwaukee Public Schools board has failed to follow a state law requiring the district's...

GOP Lawmakers Want Legislative Auditors to Review MPS Finances

(The Center Square) – Republicans at the Wisconsin Capitol don’t want Gov. Tony Evers to waste the chance to get a good look at Milwaukee Public Schools’ shortcomings.

Evers recently called for an operational and an instructional audit of MPS.

“I’m proposing today to go two steps further with two important goals: the first, to audit MPS’ programs and operations in their entirety, and the second, to audit the effectiveness of teaching and instruction of our kids in classrooms across the district,” Evers said.

The governor, however, wants to keep the audit within his administration and the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction.

Senate Majority Leader Devin LeMahieu said that’d be a mistake.

“I’m glad that Gov. Evers has called for an audit of the Milwaukee Public School System. Gov. Evers and DPI should work with Joint Legislative Audit Committee Co-Chairs [Eric] Wimberger and [Robert] Wittke to discuss authorizing the non-partisan Legislative Audit Bureau to audit MPS, DPI and any other involved stakeholders,” LeMahieu said. “The LAB is more than capable of handling this important undertaking independently and transparently without the use of outside contractors.”

The worry is an audit controlled by the governor’s office will not fully look into MPS’s shortcomings.

The calls for audits in Milwaukee Public Schools come after the state withheld nearly $17 million last week because of incomplete and late financial reports. One of those reports was due to the Department of Public Instruction in September 2023.

Evers has asked MPS leaders to be a part of any audit process but warned that not everyone will be invited.

“I also have to say – I’m exceedingly disappointed by the politicking and jockeying I’ve seen since this situation came to light by opportunists who’re seizing this moment to serve their own selfish goals instead of worrying about what matters most: our kids,” Evers added.

Republican Assembly Speaker Robin Vos took to social media to accuse the governor of being the one who is playing politics.

“And who do you think [Evers] will suggest conducts the audits?” Vos asked. “The same failed DPI bureaucrats who allowed this to happen or his administration who wanted to dismantle the school choice system so all kids were forced into this MPS mess? We need real reforms to the current mentality where MPS has been protecting the bureaucracy and Gov. Evers has been advocating for shoveling hundreds of millions of dollars into this broken system.”

Report Clearing Biden Biden Approval Rating Americore Biden Acknowledge Hamas Biden Tells Israel Not to Occupy Gaza Biden impeachment Supreme Court Strikes Down Biden’s Student Loan Cancellation

Biden’s New Staffing Requirements Put Most Illinois Nursing Homes in Peril

An industry group says the Biden administration’s new staffing regulations for long-term care facilities are unrealistic.

The mandate requires that all nursing homes that receive Medicare and Medicaid funding provide a total of at least 3.48 hours of nursing care per resident per day. Plus, nursing homes must have a registered nurse onsite at all times.

Research by shows 82%, or nearly 12,000 facilities in the U.S., will need to hire staff or face being shut down.

Spokesperson Corie Wagner said Illinois is home to the fifth highest number of understaffed nursing homes in the country.

“If we were to apply the new policies and new standards to nursing homes in Illinois today, 84% of facilities would need more staff, and that is really significant,” said Wagner.

The mandate will be phased in over three years, with rural communities having up to five years.

Nursing home operators strongly objected to the minimum staffing proposal in September, saying they already struggle to fill open positions.

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services in September announced a $75 million campaign to increase the number of nurses in nursing homes.

Nearly 1.2 million residents live in Medicare- and Medicaid-certified, long-term care facilities, but Wagner said that number is expected to increase.

“It’s called the Silver Tsunami, so more Americans are aged 65 or older than ever,” said Wagner. “It's one of the largest segments of our population but the infrastructure we have is not keeping up with our population shift.”

A resolution aimed at overturning Biden’s nursing home staffing mandate has a legitimate chance to pass the U.S. Senate.

tammy baldwin

Protesters Shout at Sen. Tammy Baldwin at Wisconsin Democratic Convention [VIDEO]

Pro-Palestinian protesters shouted at U.S. Sen. Tammy Baldwin at the state Democratic Convention in Milwaukee...
mps referendum

Milwaukee Public Schools Must Immediately Halt Referendum Spending

Milwaukee Public Schools must immediately halt all spending authorized by the narrowly passed $252 million...

Milwaukee Aldermen Call Out Gov. Evers for Not Sharing MPS Problems With Public

Two Milwaukee aldermen are calling out Gov. Tony Evers' office, questioning why Evers did not...
trump waukesha

Trump Trial Travesty: Let’s Not Lose Hope [Up Against the Wall]

What can I say that others haven’t already said? First, let’s not lose hope. Trump...