Monday, October 3, 2022
Monday, October 3, 2022

Milwaukee Press Club 'Excellence in Wisconsin Journalism' 2020 & 2021 Award Winners

HomeBreaking NewsRacine County Supervisor Demands Response From Evers on Killers' Paroles

Racine County Supervisor Demands Response From Evers on Killers’ Paroles


“It is reprehensible that your administration failed to follow State Law and make any reasonable attempts to notify the victims’ families of the violent offender’s release back into our society” – a Racine County supervisor to Gov. Tony Evers.

A Racine County Supervisory is demanding that Gov. Tony Evers explain why his Parole Commission appointee released two murderers in local cases without properly notifying victims’ families, accusing the governor’s administration of failing to follow state law.

“I am a Racine County Supervisor within Western Racine County,” Supervisor Taylor Wishau wrote the governor on Sept. 16, 2022. Evers, his Lt. Gov. Mandela Barnes, the Parole Commission, and Attorney General Josh Kaul have all refused to comment on the specific paroles cited by Wishau and the victim notification issues, which were exposed by Wisconsin Right Now.

“I write you today on behalf of my community and constituency due to the shocking news reports of your administration paroling Wilson Lee Brook and Mark Ketterhagen in 2019,” wrote Wishau. “It is also reprehensible to me that your administration failed to follow Wisconsin law (WI Statute 304.06 – Paroles from State Prisons and House of Correction) by failing to notify the victims’ families of the release of these two men.”

Wilson lee brook
Wilson lee brook. Janesville gazette, via newspapers. Com.

We previously wrote stories about the paroles of Brook, who murdered a Burlington police sergeant, Sgt. Anthony Eilers, and Ketterhagen, who murdered a pregnant teenager, Cathy Ziebell, and threw her body off a bridge. The police officer’s son and the pregnant teen’s brother (the closest kin of the victims) told Wisconsin Right Now they did not know the men had even been paroled. Wisconsin law requires the state to make a reasonable attempt to reach victims’ families in parole cases. The Burlington Police Department also did not know Brook was granted parole in 2019. Brook is now deceased, although he lived until at least July 30, 2021, per a family obituary. Ketterhagen, 69, who was also granted parole in 2019, lives in West Allis.

Cathy ziebell

We reported that the Evers/Barnes administration’s Parole Commission has released almost 1,000 criminals from 2019-2021 on parole. More than 270 are convicted of homicide offenses, some attempted murders but most murders. Child rapists and other violent criminals are among those released.

We also reported that multiple victims’ families did not know the killers had even been paroled or didn’t find out for a year after the parole. Lack of proper victim notification in the case of convicted wife killer Douglas Balsewicz last spring was cited by Evers when he belatedly pushed his appointee to the parole commission, John Tate, to rescind that release and then to resign. However, Evers’ action in that instance shows he did have the power to do something on the other, earlier, cases, but he did not. Furthermore, both Evers and Barnes have called for the prison population to be reduced by 50%.

Evers’ reappointed Tate, saying he was “pleased” to do so AFTER many of the parole cases.

Wilson brook
Parole commission records obtained through open records.

Wishau’s letter to Evers continues:

“To provide background, the now deceased Wilson Lee Brook murdered Burlington Police Sgt. Anthony Eilers by slugging him with a heavy object, beating him about the face, and then ultimately shooting the officer five times via the head and chest. It’s disturbing to know that this man was granted parole once before yet then went on to commit another burglary and escaped from prison just to flee to another state only to be caught due to America’s Most Wanted. My constituents and I demand answers as to why all of this was overlooked by your administration.

Mark Ketterhagen is the second individual your administration paroled in 2019 for the murder of a 16-year-old and pregnant Cathy Ziebell and her unborn baby. He shot her four times and then tossed her body into the Fox River. Her brother Raymond Ziebell (my former 5th-grade teacher) had to identify the body. My constituents and I demand answers as to why all of this was overlooked by your administration.

It is reprehensible that your administration failed to follow State Law and make any reasonable attempts to notify the victims’ families of the violent offender’s release back into our society. It is unfathomable that your admiration would parole over 884 convicted criminals of which 270 are murderers or attempted murderers and 44 are child rapists. How can I and my constituents trust you or your administration to follow Wisconsin Law and ensure our communities remain safe? I have zero faith in your ability Governor to ensure our communities across Wisconsin will remain safe from these individuals.

These families deserve answers, our communities deserve answers. Will you personally provide a response on this?”

Jim Piwowarczyk
Jim Piwowarczyk is an investigative journalist and co-founder of Wisconsin Right Now. Married with 3 kids, a chocolate lab, and a german shepherd. Jim served as a police officer in Wisconsin for more than 20 years. His career started as a police officer in Milwaukee County in 1994 as a patrol officer, until he was promoted to patrol sergeant in 2003 where he worked until he left in 2009 to pursue business aspirations. Jim Piwowarczyk was a field training officer, evidence technician & hostage negotiator and conducted many drug investigations. Jim continued to work part-time for an area police department. Jim is avid real estate investor, and small business owner & developer. Jim has coached youth football and basketball. Jim is also an avid fisherman and hunter.

Latest Articles